Mike Moffatt: Declining Sales and Jobs—The Case for Lowering Taxes on New Homes in Canada
The Canadian housing market is currently navigating a troubling landscape characterized by declining home prices and rents, juxtaposed with steadfast construction costs. Despite a notable decrease in demand, evidenced by over an 80% drop in new home sales across the Greater Toronto Area and other key markets, the construction industry faces a paradox where affordability remains elusive for middle-class families, while development continues to be economically unfeasible.
As home prices dip, the persistent high costs associated with new construction remain a significant barrier. With total construction costs often exceeding what buyers can afford, both homeowners and builders are left in a precarious stalemate. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation has forecast a decline of approximately 30,000 housing starts between 2024 and 2027, posing severe implications for employment. Should these projections materialize, industry estimates suggest the loss of around 100,000 jobs across various sectors, not only affecting trades such as electricians and plumbers but also impacting supply chains that provide essential materials.
The crux of the issue lies in taxation policies that render new homes economically unviable to build. Taxes, including the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and province-specific levies, significantly inflate the cost structure, making it increasingly difficult for developers to maintain profitability while still catering to a market that is financially constrained. Historical comparisons indicate that taxes and fees alone can equate to the entire cost of a home from two decades ago, underscoring the escalating barriers facing the industry.
The federal government’s initiatives, such as the Build Canada Homes program and the First-Time Home Buyer GST rebate, have been criticized for lacking substantive impact. Without concrete modeling or forecasting to substantiate claims that these measures will adequately stimulate growth in housing starts, there remains a palpable disconnect between policy rhetoric and market realities.
To align fiscal policies with real-world housing needs, stakeholders across all levels of government must prioritize substantial reductions in construction costs. This includes cutting tax burdens on new home projects and reevaluating development charges that inhibit housing affordability. Enhanced focus on fiscal alignment with the urgent need for increased supply is essential to prevent further job losses and stave off a deeper housing crisis.
In conclusion, the current state of the Canadian housing market necessitates urgent action to tackle both construction cost barriers and taxation issues to ensure that housing remains accessible to middle-class families while supporting the economic stability of the construction industry.
📋 Article Summary
-
Unaffordable Housing: Despite falling prices, many Canadian home prices remain out of reach for middle-class families, exacerbated by high construction costs.
-
Decline in Home Sales: New home sales have plummeted over 80% compared to 2021, indicating a severe market downturn not reflected in current housing start statistics.
-
Impact on Employment: Forecasts predict a loss of 30,000 housing starts by 2027, which could lead to the loss of 100,000 jobs in the construction sector.
- Need for Tax Reform: Current tax policies are making new homes economically unviable to build; significant reductions in taxes and fees are necessary to make homebuilding feasible again.
🏗️ Impact for Construction Professionals
The recent decline in new home sales and projected reductions in housing starts present both challenges and opportunities for construction professionals.
Practical Business Implications: As construction costs rise due to taxes and fees, it’s vital to reassess your pricing strategies. Consider implementing value engineering to optimize costs without compromising quality.
Opportunities and Challenges: The predicted reduction of 30,000 housing units could lead to fewer projects, but it also opens avenues for advocating tax reforms that could lower construction costs. Engage with local governments to push for policy changes that support viable housing projects.
Actionable Insights: Streamline operations by embracing innovative construction techniques or materials that reduce expenses. Collaborate with suppliers to negotiate better rates, ensuring competitiveness in increasingly tight margins.
Day-to-Day Operations and Strategic Planning: Regularly review your project pipeline and adjust forecasts based on market trends. Develop contingency plans for potential workforce reductions. Emphasize adaptability in your strategy, as the construction landscape may shift rapidly in response to government actions and housing demand. Addressing these factors can help you stay resilient amid changing market conditions.
#Mike #Moffatt #Falling #sales #falling #jobs #Canada #cut #taxes #homes
